INTRODUCTION
Dr Inge as THE TRACE ELEMENT EXPERT
I have had as personal friends many of the early giants in the field, Harry
Schroeder (I treasure a complete set of preprints, often with a hand written
note), Isabel Tipton (I called her my American mother), George Cotzias (that
wonderful bear of a man, who spoke the most perfect English, must have been
all that Greek training), D.P. de Villiers (who did so much to prevent
pre-eclampsia with his vitamin and trace element pills, when the Cape Flats
was the eclampsia captital of the world in the 1950s), Lesley Bidstrup
(still active in the UK courts in her mid-80s), Prof Kench (of early cadmium
fame, who was one of my PhD examiners and welcomed me back with a hug 20
years later) and just so many more!
I was a founding-charter member of SEGH (Society for Environmental
Geochemistry and Health), back in the 1960s. I have attended more select
conferences (often international), than I care to remember, although there
were always humerous moments and it was delightful to make new friends and
hug old ones. I have walked mining sites, both ancient and modern. I have
observed in the field many sorts of major occupational and environmental
problems. I have been the external reviewer of key governmental and
international reviews in several countries for over 30 years. Name it and I
have very probably done it!
Knowledge can be a very precious gift. So email me!
Why do I charge?
Will I tell you if I cannot help you?
Arsenic is an essential trace element and
too little is toxic, just as, too much is also
toxic. It was one of the world's first
medicines (in China and Egypt for a start)
as well as one of its notorious poisons.
However, in Arsenic and Old Lace, the entity
was probably strychnine not arsenic.
For many years we have been told that
arsenic is a deadly carcinogen. At best
(or worst), it is a type of co-carcinogen and
only produces tumors under fairly well
defined, metabolic circumstances. There
are millions of third world people who are
at risk from arsenical poisoning, mainly due
to the stupidity of officials, whose minds dwell
in neatly compartmentalized areas of
responsibility and who refuse to look at
problems and their possible solution as a whole.
It is nearly exactly a year ago, that I sat opposite
an official in another land, who feared for his own
life and those near and dear to him, because there
had been many deaths in his village due to incorrect
installed of tube wells, which had thus spread arsenic
pollution even further, rather than solving the problem.
He want a magic elixir from me to keep them safe. It
was with great reluctance, that he slowly started to
answer my questions. How does your family's diet
compare with those who are ill? - We eat fairly well,
those who are dying were malnourished to begin with.
What are the present levels of arsenic and selenium in
the water in your village tube wells? - arsenic 2x
WHO (World Health Organization) drinking water
standard levels, but, selenium we could not measure,
it was so low. My guess is that most of the "middle
and upper" economic classes, because of their
reasonable food intake will be OK healthwise.
However, the number of deaths in the rest of the
population will continue to mount.
What do I base my crystal ball predictions on?
The figures we base our risk assessments on,
come from a dirt poor third world community.
Their occupations required them to stand in arsenic
containing water and mud for many hours a day.
Their drinking water stood in uncovered vats,
filthy with green slime and red algae and fungi.
They ate meat (pork) once per year. They ate fish
heads and tails only (the rest of the fish was sold).
They had no fruit in their diet and their vegetables
were reed type grasses. The bulk of what they
ate was a sweet potato type tuber, which was
dried for storage, except most of the time it was
moldy. Why is this not told in the scientific papers?
Yes, it was told right at the beginning by a US
naval doctor. However, then 2 things happened,
(a) the local national government started sending
in free rice and improving the water supply, the
reason why this had not been done previously,
was because the population at risk, was the local
aboriginal peoples, who counted for little in the eyes
of the fairly new central government and (b) all
descriptions of the diet etc were expunged for good
from documents - the diet had "always" included
rice, etc, etc, was what it states in all the papers
from 1963 on!!!
I have been in many parts of the world, seeking to
understand from a practical point of view, when do
you see arsenic toxicity and when do you not. The
old standard levels of arsenic in drinking water are
borderline toxic (that is when you add up the total
arsenic content in food plus drinking water per day
etc) for a long-term malnourishing, low selenium,
low vitamin, low calorie diet. If the person is well
nourished, with normal to high levels of selenium,
normal vitamin levels and a reasonable caloric intake,
the arsenic oral intake may be increased from 2 to 4
fold before chronic toxicity becomes prevalent.
Yes, I am deeply concerned about the levels of arsenic
in the drinking water of at least 6 nations, but the U.S. is
not one of them!!! I would much prefer public funds to be
spent on any of a score of "good" causes, rather than
be used in yet another round of "lower the arsenic
drinking water standard". This does *not* mean, I don't
think industrial arsenic pollution should not be cleaned
up. I definitely do! However, I just don't think cleaning up
Mother Nature's natural arsenic levels, a worthwhile
endeavor.
Traditionally, we are told, we must be deficient in calcium if:
we suffer from pains in our joints, muscle cramps and
twitching (tetany); numbness and tingling (paresthesia),
hyperirritability, convulsions, bone disorders, such as,
rickets in children, osteomalitis and osteoporosis
(demineralization) in adults, heart palpitations and slow pulse
rates. Also during pregnancy, lactation, PMS, for aging,
arthitis, during aging, insomnia and with some dental and
gum disorders. However, the answer is *usually* not so
*simple*. The first things to consider is *not only* absolute
amounts, BUT RATIOS. Calcium *never* works in a vacuum
and its "sisters (VERY close working partners/allies), cousins
(close working allies/partners) and aunts" (the key metabolic
systems within which it works) MUST be taken into account!!!
SISTERS: Magnesium, Vitamin D and phosphorus
Some factors that can cause our bodies to lack calcium:
Good natural sources of calcium include, milk and its products, dark
green vegetables, nuts, seeds, grains and beans, sardines and egg yolks.
Officially Recommended Dietary Allowance (RDA) for calcium is
1.2g (grams) per day. The ratio of calcium to phosphorus is 1:1.
The ratio of calcium to magnesium is officially about 1:3 or lower,
although in many supplements it is 1:2.
Chromium (+3) is a critical component
of the glucose tolerance factor (GTF). This
factor contains niacin, glycine, glutamic acid
and cysteine, in addition to, chromium (+3).
Chromium (+3) and insulin are both involved
in glucose metabolism. Chromium (+3) is
also important in the metabolism of cholesterol
and is an integral part many enzymic and
hormonal reactions.
The proper functioning of chromium (+3) is
important in diabetes, hypoglycemia, heart
disease and pregnancy. But too much is as
bad as too little!!! Thus excess chronic
ingestion of chromium (+3) can reverse the
normal function and inhibit rather than enhance
insulin activity.
Marginal chromium deficiency is now common
place, particularly in the elderly and probably
also in people who regularly excise strenuously
and do not eat particularly healthy diets.
The major depleting factors are refined foods,
refined sugars and aging. However, please do
not believe all the health food store adverts,
rather eat a healthy diet and watch your intake
of refined foods and snacks and refined sugars.
Natural sources of chromium (+3) included,
Brewer's yeast, whole grained foods, wheat
germ, grape juice, molasses, mushrooms,
oysters, egg yolk and thyme.
Sisters: Vitamin B3 (niacin), amino acids (glycine,
glutamic acid, cysteine)
Officially Recommended Daily Allowance (RDA)
- 50 to 200ug/day (50 to 200mcg/day)
Usual daily amounts eaten by the elderly seem to
be as low as 10 to 25ug/day (10 to 50mcg/day)
and many people have diets with amounts below
100ug/day.
What should a person do? Try to eat more whole
grained rather refined products or add Brewer's
yeast or wheat germ to your cooking or if you want
to take a supplement, choose a plain one (no fancy
amino acid chelates or GTF) and a value of about
100ug/day (100mcg/day), certainly no higher than
200ug/day (200mcg/day).
(NOTE: There have been a few reports of kidney damage at 1200 mcg/day or more taken daily for several months).
While true copper excess and deficiency
diseases exist, most impaired use of copper
in bodily systems is due to ratio imbalances
of copper and certain other key trace elements,
such as copper together with iron or iron and zinc
or molybdenum and sulfate, as well as the type of
carbohydrate consumed.
High intakes of zinc or calcium or Vitamin C
can inhibit copper absorption, (as do mercury
and silver). However, zinc deficiency can also
accentuate an excess of copper.
Imbalances have been known to occur in certain
bone diseases, atherosclerosis, heart disease,
blood diseases and breathing difficulties.
Copper is found in nuts, wheat bran, wheat germ,
Brewer's yeast, soybeans, seafood and liver and
kidneys.
Sisters - Iron, zinc, molybdenum-suphate complex
Officially Recommended Dietary Allowancea (RDA)
- 2mg/day
Fluoride is a trace element ion and hence
it has a deficiency toxicity level (which could
be lower, equal or greater than the normal
background level of fluoride in food plus
water intake) and an excess toxicity level.
The difference between these two levels is
the normal safe range. Please always
remember the first rule of toxicology - "Only
the dose makes the poison". However,
*both* toxicity levels and hence the safe range
can and will be modified by a whole range of
factors. Consideration needs to be given to:
In any human bone or tooth studies, magnesium
and protein need to be considered along with
calcium and phosphorus. In cancer and other
human disease studies, it is also necessary to
discover if *all* possible causes have been
considered.
When determining legal or proposed limits it is
*extremely* important to compare "apples" with
"apples" and ask what assumptions have been
made. How much does the adult male and female,
the various ages of children and infants, weigh,
eat per day and drink per day. Watch out for mg or
ug per day versus mg or ug per kilogram of weight
per day. If the so called "market basket" of foods
is being cited, what years are being used and what
is the range of values across country. Also are safety
factors included, if so, what are they and how were
they derived? *One very big problem in assessing
data is that TOTAL INTAKE should always include
food + water + toothpaste*. However, it OFTEN
includes *only* water or *only* food, so watch out!
Normally, the assumption is made that an adult male
weights 70kg, an adult female 55kg (although I have
seen from 50 to 60kg) and that both drink 2 liters of
water (liquid) per day, although in hot climates 3 liters
is often used. It is also often assumed that adults eat
1kg of food per day. Children and infants are often
scaled by weight off these figures.
What have to be determined are the deficiency and
excess toxicity levels for (food + water). This is not
as simple as it seems. For example, if we know
there is a high prevalence of reduced bone density
and collapsed vertebrae in humans in an area with
low-fluoride water (0.15-0.30mg per liter), how do
we determine the highest level at which this will not
happen? And how do we build in safety factors?
Then at the other "end", if we know that a *total* intake
of 20-50mg per day may lead to severe bone and
kidney problems in humans, how again do we
determine the lowest level at which this will not happen?
And how again do we build in adequate safety factors?
Other studies of minimal effects in humans, seem to
indicate a no-adverse-effect-level (NOAEL) to a
lowest-adverse-effect-level (LOAEL) of 8-10mg per day
total intake of food and water.
All these studies exist, *but* none have been adequately
confirmed. The problem is that the ranges between
deficiency toxicity, background and excess toxicity are
VERY SMALL and total intake, food plus water, are often
not measured using the same groups of people
(population).
A *sample* set of levels might be as follows:
The following *Contaminant* Regulation is of interest:
Recommended Dietary Allowances (RDA) are the people
who are saying total intake:
The
food data and natural background water levels and the
deficiency toxicity and excess toxicity levels need very
careful accessment. Any
discussion on fluoridation (AND AT WHAT LEVEL OF
ADDITION, for example, 0 or 0.25mg or 0.5 or 1mg per
liter) needs to have a firm basis for argument (pro or con).
Please note, the discussion on fluoridation should always
include a LEVEL, and a Risk Assessment.
(PLEASE always remember TOTAL oral intake =
Water (2 liters) + Food (+ toothpaste) *not just one
section of it*!!!)
Iodine is present in foods mainly as the iodide,
but also, organically, bound to amino acids.
Iodide is rapidly and almost completely absorbed
orally and also, which is unusual, via the skin.
Iodine is unevenly distributed in the environment.
It is estimated that there are 1,000 -2,500 million
people who suffer from iodine deficiency, mainly,
"deficiency" goiter. However, in some developing
countries, the deficiency may be at least partially
due to the "excess" consumption of plants containing
natural goitrogens, such as the staple food cassava.
The goitrogens interfere in the iodine-thyroid-hormone
production. These compounds are present in cabbage,
rutabagas, cauliflowers, turnips and some nuts.
Just to increase the general confusion, a *high* intake
of iodine can lead to another type of goiter. Normally
this "toxic" intake must be greater than *1mg/day*.
Natural sources of iodine include, seafood, kelp, sea
weeds, fish liver oils, eggs, cheddar cheese, peanuts,
sunflower seeds and pineapples. The most usual,
first world, source is iodized salt. It should be noted that
iodates are sometimes used as bread dough oxidizers,
iodine-containing disinfectants may be used in
commercial milk production and iodine may be an
additive in animal feeds.
The metabolism of iodine can be antagonized by large
intakes of nitrates, resorcinol and cobalt.
The Officially Recommended Dietary Allowance (RDA)
for iodine is 150ug/day (150mcg/day), with pregnant
and lactating women 175-200ug/day. A high to "super"
amount would be 300-400ug/day, a deficiency, for an
adult, would be about 50ug/day.
Sisters and cousins - Various hormones such as, insulin,
progesterone, cortisol and serotonin
Iron, like several other essential elements, is actively,
rather than passively, transported across the gut wall.
This means that there is a regulatory system which
controls the uptake of iron. Normally about 10% of
the iron fed, is absorbed. The regulatory mechanism
also acts as a type of "gate-keeper" - body deficient,
let more iron in; body excess, cut back on iron
absorbed. Now there are times when the gate-keeper
does not or can not do its job properly, for example,
there is a genetic condition which results in excess
iron in the body, or times in our life cycle when we could
be more prone to iron deficiency (infancy, adolescence
and pregnancy) or the iron presents itself to the
gate-keeper as an eye-catching person (correct
co-factors such as Vitamin C or in the form of heme) and
more iron is temporarily let in or as an ugly person
(co-factors such as phytates, oxalates and phosphates)
less iron is let in. But in general, the iron intake is pretty
well regulated, a *fact forgotten in most lay texts* and
also in some high level ones. With regard to the latter,
I had a good laugh when a National Research Council
(NRC) text stated, "..without genetic defects that
increase iron absorption, there are no reports of iron
toxicity from foods other than long-term ingestion of
home brews made in iron vessels", the NRC did not
realize that these particular people *actually had the
genetic defect too*.
I have seen many articles claiming, iron-xyz is *the* iron
product to use. Don't you believe it, unless they have
well conducted absorption experiments to prove it.
I have seen too many experiments where the "wonder"
product comes in, well down the list of absorbability.
Also, I remember too well, a series of experiments
seeking to prove the iron deficiency in a particular
population was caused solely by the high phytates in
their food supply. Unfortunately that was only part of
the puzzle.
The RDA total dietary levels plus supplementation for iron
are:
In general, if you believe you need more iron in your
diet, perhaps think about:
Other factors to consider are:
Iron's sisters are: Copper, zinc and Vitamin C
Magnesium plays a critical role in muscular and
neuromuscular contractions, and hence, in the functioning
of the heart muscles and vasodilation of the blood vesels.
Magnesium plays an important role in the regulation of
cellular sodium, potassium and calcium. It helps in
preventing the formation of calcium-oxalate kidney stones.
It plays a major part in the initial hardening of tooth enamel
and resistance to decay.
My first "knowledge encounter" with this hidden wonder
element was in the 1950s, when so many women in southern
Africa were dying horribly, in late pregnancy, from eclampsia.
One of my mentors was involved in using an injection
containing magnesium in the crisis, out in the "field", that is,
in the hovels of dirt-poor townships and saving the mother
and often the child too. A multi-nutrient pill containing
magnesium plus other minerals (all magnesium's "sisters,
counsins and aunts") was given free to as many pregnant
moms as the various teams of workers could get their hands
on - this helped too. Not all the pregnant women who got
eclampsia were poor. At least one ex-high school classmate
of mine suffered from it, but I suspect she did not eat
nutritious foods during pregnancy.
Why do I say, all magnesium's "sisters, cousins and aunts"?
Magnesium, chromium, cobalt, copper, fluoride, iodide, iron,
manganese, molybdenum, selenium, vanadium, zinc and also
calcium, potassium, sodium, phosphorus and sulfur *never*
work/function on their own! They always "work" closely with or
against a small group of elements and substances (sisters), are
influenced by by a larger group of elements and substances
(cousins), governed by bodily systems (aunts). This is also true
for aluminum, antimony, arsenic, barium, beryllium, bismuth,
boron, bromide, cadmium, gallium, germanium, gold, lead,
lithium, mercury, nickel, platinum, rubidium, silver, strontium,
tellurium, thallium, tin, titanium and zirconium. It is *very*
important to understand as much as we can about all these
relationships, in fact it is *very dangerous* to our health to
ignore these relationships, because health, be it on the
subcellular or metabolic level or the whole person level,
requires balance and moderation. ONLY THE DOSE MAKES
THE POISON! Too little is often as bad as too much!!!
In 1993, I was taking part in a high level trace element
conference in Europe and at the end of nearly every paper, either
I or a young Prof (who it turned out was trained by one of my two
PhD classmates) would jump up and ask the following two key
questions:
Well, who are magnesium's sisters? Calcium, phosphorus, and
Vitamin D. Whereas close cousin's include manganese, zinc,
Vitamin B6 and Vitamin C. The aunt's are the muscular systems
etc, described above.
What foods are high in magnesium? Whole grains, seafood,
brown rice, green leafy vegitables, apples, lemons, soybeans
and almonds are all good sources, but not the only ones.
Next question is obviously, should I take a supplement and if so
what should I take? Ideally our foods should provide all we need.
However, it does not always work out that way, for many reasons.
I hope later down the series you will get a better feel for what it is
correct for your own body. I need to write on absorption, excretion
and metabolism. I *will* recap after I have written on calcium,
copper, iron, potassium and zinc, which together with magnesium,
make up what I call the major trace elements. Later I will deal with
the minor trace elements, such as chromium and again recap.
I will also write on the vitamins (then recap) and the major "building
blocks", such as fatty acids, fats, fiber etc. So please be patient
with me, because I want to give you background information, before
talking about integrating the "picture" for your own particular needs.
I leave you today with some passing thoughts. Multi-vitamin-mineral
pills serve the same purpose as a one-size-fits-all muu-muu. In
addition, taking high levels of vitamins-minerals all the time leaves
you nowhere to go when your body really need them. Also they
become like a child's safety blanket - just a habit with little true
safety
attached, except what is in the mind, which is very important too.
Yes, I do have both Vitamin and Mineral tablets in the house and I
do use them, but not every day.
RDA levels:
Recommended "upper" limit of supplementation for men, women, pregnancy and lactating females - 350 mg/day
Manganese is a trace element we hear
toxic warning about, in its *organic* forms
and also about in its *inhaled inorganic*
forms. But in this vignette, I am *only*
talking about *oral inorganic* manganese.
You may well ask, once an element gets into
the body, does the body care about the route
of entery or whether it was inorganic or
organic? The answer is both yes and no.
Crudely, with inhalation, very often the toxicity
of the element(s) occurs in the lungs before
they are fully absorbed into the body. Also
crudely, certain organic forms of elements
are often toxic because the organic part of
the molecule increases the toxicity of the
inorganic part and/or the whole molecule
mimics an essential entity of the body in
size or shape or other key property.
Oral inorganic manganese is *essential* to
the mammalian body. It is involved as an
enzyme catalyst in carbohydrate, mucopoly-
sacharide, fat and protein metabolism, in
reproduction, including sex hormone production
and the functioning of the mammary glands and
in the nourishment of nerve and brain cells. It is
vital to thiamine (Vitamin B1) metabolism and
Vitamin E utilization. Known manganese metallo-
enzymes, include pyruvate carboxylase and
superoxide dismutase and there are many
enzymes requiring less specific catalysis by
inorganic manganese.
Both human deficiency and excess toxicities
exist, but rarely "happen". Little is really known
about "borderline" deficiencies, because of the
interlinking of nutrients which invalidates many
of the normal experimental procedures. Testing
for 3 or more components for interactions (say,
manganese, iron, zinc - deficiency, normal,
excess) is costly and seldom done. Perhaps
now, as modelling improves, more can be
accomplished. Model and find out certain key
entities we need to test for and do those
experiments first.
Manganese is present in tea, nuts, whole grain
products, green leafy vegetables, bananas,
apricots, blueberries, pineapples, egg yolk and
brussel sprouts.
Depletion may occur from eating an excess of
refined foods, excess soy protein and abnormally
high amounts of calcium and phosphorus.
Sisters - Chromium, iron, choline, thiamine
Officially Recommended Dietary Allowances (RDA)
- 2mg/day
Among the many uses of organic mercury was its use as a fungicide on seed grains. In the early 1970s several thousand people in Iraq were poisoned, when they ate US supplied seed grain, rather than planting it. This happened elsewhere too, but not in such large numbers.
The most publicized "mercury" poisoning arises from the ingestion of fish containing methylmercury (NOT mercury), whose food chain has become
contaminated with mercury from natural, industrial or waste sources. The big question becomes, "Will I get poisoned if I eat fish, every day or every week or every month?". Please remember, only the dose makes the poison, but the effect dose is modified by what else one eats (for example, how much zinc) and what the general state of ones health is, particularly, in this instance, is one pregnant. Standards have been setup based on human research on 3 communities in widely separate areas of the world and safety factors have been added.
If you feel safer eating only fish-farmed fish, with a sea fish meal thrown in as a treat several times a month, please do so. However, having your blood and/or urine tested is in my opinion a waste of money, even insurance money. Also, PLEASE do not fall for the chelation therapy fad. Chelation treatment in cases of true mercury poisoning is very specialized and the type used depends on the specific type of mercury received. Chelation therapy, particularly if you do not need it could seriously damage your
health!
There are, at least, two types of known
human molybdenum deficiency toxicities.
Following long-term total parenteral
feeding, lack of molybdenum led to an
amino acid intolerance, with increased
urinary excretion of xanthine and sulfite
and decreased urinary excretion of uric
acid and sulfate. Whereas, in the second
type a rare inborn metabolic error led to
a lack of molybdopterin, the molybdenum
co-factor of the enzymes sulfite oxidase
and also xanthine oxidase.
At the other end of the spectrum, excess
levels of molybdenum (10-15mg/day) have
led to a goutlike syndrome associated
with high levels of molybdenum, uric acid
and xanthine oxidase in human blood.
However, even at 540ug of molybdenum
per day (540mcg/day or 0.54mg/day)
losses of copper in the urine have been
observed.
In the US the average dietary intake is in
the average range 100-200ug per day.
The Official Recommended Dietary
Allowances are as follows:
Sisters - Copper and sulfur
It is obvious more research needs to be done
on this trace element. Analytical problems
have deterred many a research project up
to now.
This is a particularly interesting element, because
we have very well documented human cases of
deficiency (toxicity) as well as, (excess) toxicity. In
addition, the minute you say or think Vitamin E, the
next words should be, "and selenium".
In the Western U.S.and elsewhere in the world,
there are many areas where the soils are overly
blessed with selenium and/or there are plants
which accumulate selenium. This often leads to
stock poisoning, sometimes called "alkali disease"
or "blind staggers".
In Keshan, China, where they have one of the soil
selenium "deficiency" spots in the world, the local
people, particularly, the pregnant women and children,
developed an endemic cardiomyopathy. This finding
was first international presented to scientists in Perth,
Australia in May 1981. It was extremely frustrating to
be unable to understand a single word of the paper!!!
Even written questions, proved "non-rewarding". What
was also strange, was that there appeared to be no
other scientist present, who spoke a common language
with these particular delegates, something which was
unlikely to have occurred even 5 years later!
Key uses of selenium, include binding or complexing with
several heavy metals, thus protecting and detoxifying
certain vital systems. It is a component of the glutathione
peroxidase system, which protects against certain
oxidative reactions. Selenium and Vitamin E work together
in growth, fertility and other metabolic functions of the body.
And selenium is involved in the general cytochrome P450
detoxification of xenobiotics, a loose term often applied
to pollutants. Many people consider selenium is helpful
in heart disease and as a protection against cancer. It is
very difficult to prove or disprove this, since most often, key
parts of the puzzle get left out. It is reasonably easy to test
for 2 interlinking factors (selenium plus say, Vitamin E and
the glutathionine system), but harder to test for 3 (selenium
plus say, Vitamin E, the glutathione system and sulfur amino
acids), etc, etc. Usually one ends up with at least 6 probable
interlinking factors and the costs of experimentation go
skyward and hence are unlikely to take place. Except now,
as computer modelling improves, various possibilities arise,
so here is hoping! Yes, I think selenium and Vitamin E, in
moderation, can be of help in some "heart" problems. In
certain "cancers", which are known to be probably due, in
some measure, to metallic overexposure, yes, selenium
could be of use, but ratios of metals to selenium and other
factors need to be considered. Hence, for "heart" problems,
a probable yes, and for certain "cancers", a qualified yes.
Good food sources of selenium - Brewer's yeast, nuts, cheddar
cheese, sea foods, grains (if not over-purified), garlic, etc.
Sisters - Vitamin E, glutathione, arsenic
*Please remember* selenium is measure in *micrograms*
per day not milligrams/day. The usual symbol for micrograms
is ug, but the health food people write it as mcg, (milligrams
are written as mg).
The Official Recommended Dietary Allowance (adult males)
is 70ug/day;
As with all essential elements, deficiency diseases can
exist, but they are fairly rare. In additional, our gut
absorption processes actively regulate how much we
absorb, thus for the most part our bodies get neither
too little nor too much! However, the general rule
remains, too little and also too much is bad for us.
Zinc is sometimes thought to be able to produce "wonders"
on its own, for example, pop a zinc pill and cure a cold!
Sorry it does not work that way. In general, you would need
at a minimum, Vitamin A as well, next you would to have to
fool the "gut gatekeeper" and unfortunately, a cold lasts a
week, if you take pills, you may feel better, but the cold will
still last 7 days!
Factors that help deplete our bodies of zinc include stress,
alcohol, diabetes, high cholesterol and high amounts of
copper, iron, cadmium and calcium.
Natural sources of zinc, include, oysters (hence they are
sometimes called aphrodisiacs), herring, sprouted seeds
and grains, pumpkin and sunflower seeds, nuts, eggs,
brewer's yeast, soybeans, etc.
Sisters - Vitamin A, copper, phosphorus
In general, males require slightly more zinc than non-pregnant,
non-lactating females. But please do not take supplements greater than these values.
Recommended Daily Allowances (RDA)
But please don't take supplements greater than these values.
RosettaStoneInc.com Home Page
TRACE ELEMENTS
Why am I the experts expert?
Although sometimes working in a peripheral field, since my teens, I have
made trace elements my especial field of interest and study. That is close
to 50 years experience and experience plus book-learning what a combination!
I have sadly learned that people, businesses, governments and agencies equate
money charged with value given. Therefore, free help, has no value in their
eyes. Very sad but unfortunately true.
Definitely, why waste your time and mine. Time is too precious to waste in
this run-run-run era!
INGE'S TERMS: SISTERS, COUSINS & AUNTS
Key substances in the body such as
vitamins and trace elements NEVER
function/work on their own. They
always "work/function" closely with
OR against a small group of elements
or substances, which I call "SISTERS".
In addition key substances are also
influenced
by a larger group of elements or
substances which I am calling
"COUSINS" and these are all
governed by bodily systems which
I am calling "AUNTS"
ALUMINUM/ALUMINIUM
Bound as aluminosilicates and oxides, aluminum is the most abundant metal in
the earth's crust. Aluminum is not an essential nutrient for humans.
However, goats fed low aluminum diets have been reported to have depressed
growth, decreased life expectancy, lack of co-ordination and weakness in
their hind legs and an increased number of spontaneous abortions. Chicks on
low aluminum diets have depressed growth. In humans the typical daily
intake is 2-8mg, much of this is often from food additives. Toxic effects
can occur in patients with chronic renal failure, the aluminum coming from
the dialysis fluids and/or medications that they receive. Although still
controversial, aluminum in the diet does not seem to be a contributing
factor in such disorders as Alzeheimer's disease.
ARSENIC
They put arsenic in his meat
And stared agast to watch him eat;
- I tell the tale that I heard told,
Mithridates, he died old!
- A.E. Housman (1859-1936)
BORON
This is a dietary trace element found mainly in plant foods. It is
essential for plant growth and in at least some fish. It may also be
essential in humans. In recent research boron has been found to be
promoter of bone and joint health and it can influence the cellular
transport of calcium. Nutritional forms of boron are readily and nearly
completely absorbed. There is no evidence that boron promotes the
development of lean muscle mass. However, there are findings that boron can
mimic and enhance the effects of estrogen in post-menopausal women and that
estrogen replacement therapy used in conjunction with boron may produce
synergistic results. Boron appears to be of help in the treatment of
osteoarthritis by modulating the response of antigens in key immune cells
and hlping to control the inflammatory process. Boron should be taken with
calcium and magnesium (what I call its sisters) and perhaps also Vitamin D
(what I call its cousin). A deficiency level of boron would be 1-2mg per
day, a toxic level about 100-180mg per day. A normal level is probably
about 3mg per day.
CADMIUM
Cadmium is of the same chemical family as zinc and mercury. It is
considered one of the 189 listed hazardous air pollutants in the US.
However, food and cigarette smoke are normally our largest sources of
exposure. Smokers can double their daily intake of cadmium, since about
half the amount breathed in is absorbed by the lungs, whereas gut absorption
is less than 20% and some recent research indicates less than 2%. Our food
intake per day is about 2-40ppb (or Ug/Kg or mcg/Kg), the highest levels
coming from leafy vegetables and potatoes and lower levels from fruits and
beverages. Unpolluted soils normally contain about 250ppb. The risk of
health damage from intake of cadmium in day-to-day foods is really
non-existent.
CALCIUM
Almost all of the calcium in our bodies (99%) is in our
teeth and bones. However, we should not overlook
the very important 1%, which is key in such vital functions
as, nerve impulse conduction, muscle contraction, blood
clotting, membrane permeability, cell division regulation,
secretion of hormones and other metabolic processes.
Please remember our gut (intestines) only allow a certain
amount of calcium into our bodies, unless the regulation
system has gone crazy, which usually does not happen.
Take in huge "gobs" of calcium and usually it just goes out
the other end, even if it is "chelated" or some other "wonder
product".
Cousins: Potassium, Vitamin A, Vitamin C, lysine, arginine and
lactose
Aunts: Nervous system, cellular metabolic system, skeletal system
and many others
TRIVALENT CHROMIUM
This is one of the most interesting Trace
Elements. Chromium occurs as a metal
(+0), in the trivalent form (+3) which is an
essential element and as the chromate (+6)
which has many industrial uses. Today, I
will write ONLY on the trivalent form, which is
an essential trace element.
Cousins: Magnesium, zinc, Vitamin B6 (pyridoxine)
cobalt, and iron
Aunts: Glucose, insulin and cholesterol
COPPER
Copper is an essential element for all animals
and plants. It is a co-factor in many ezymes.
Copper is necessary for the absorption and
utilization of iron. It helps absorb and carry
oxygen as a component of the hemoglobin
system. Copper functions as an important
blood antioxidant. It helps maintain the
integrity of cell membranes and the myelin
sheath around nerve fibers, partially at least,
through being a co-factor in the synthesis of
phospholipids. Copper helps prevent
peroxidation of polyunsaturated fatty acids
(PUFA), is involved in collagen formation for
bone and connective tissue and in protein
metabolism healing processes of the body.
Cousins - Calcium, manganese, magnesium
Aunts - Blood system, cell and nerve membranes.
High Amounts - 3mg/gay
Super Amounts - 5mg/day
FLUORIDE
(This is a *very* hot political topic.
I have given my professional opinion on
this issue in years gone by and will no
doubt do so again. However, in this
vignette I will NOT state an opinion, but
rather attempt to pose questions and give
information, so that you can ask questions
of the opposing sides and then make
informed judgements).
(*Note* water only, so food must be added, say about
1.0 to1.5mg per day for an estimated total of
1.3-2.1mg per day).
Water 0.8-1.2mg per day (2 liters x 0.4-0.6mg per liter)
Food 0.2-0.3mg per day
Total 1.0-1.5mg per day or
0.02mg per kg of human weight per day
But we need estimates from both food and water (plus
perhaps toothpaste) all together.
EPA Maximum Drinking Water Level - 4mg per liter
EPA Integrated Risk Information System (IRIS)
No-Adverse-Effect - Level (Food plus Water) = NOAEL = 0.06mg/kg/day = 4.2mg per day
Lowest-Adverse-Effect-Level (Food plus Water) = LOAEL = 0.12mg/kg/day = 8mg per day
Adult males - 4.0mg per day;
Adult females - 3.0mg per day
Children 7-10year - 1.0mg per day
Infants - 0.5mg per day
GERMANIUM
Germanium has not been found to be an essential nutrient for humans.
However, rats fed a germanium deficient diet had altered mineral composition
of the bone and liver and decreased DNA in the tibia. For humans the daily
dietary intake of germanium seem to be in the range 0.4-1.5 mg, mainly from
vegetables, grains a fruits. There is no indication that humans become
deficient. Some forms of germanium, such as the dioxide, citrate and
lactate can be given in amounts toxic to the human liver and kidneys,
resulting in death.
IODINE
Iodine is an essential element for all mammals.
About 80% of the bodies iodine is found in the
thyroid. Iodine is an integral part of the thyroid
hormones, thyroxine and triiodothyronine. The
thyroid regulates energy production and the rate
of body metabolism, including that of excess fat
(thus also partially body weight).
Aunts - Thyroid hormones
IRON
Some of the major functions of iron include
the production of hemoglobin and myoglobin,
which transport oxygen in the blood and muscle,
respectively, its role in collagen synthesis and its
use as an enzymic cofactor, particularly in protein
metabolism and in neurotransmitter synthesis for
serotonin, dopamine and noradrenalin.
Infants -- 6-10mg/day
Children -- 10mg/day
Men -- 10-12mg/day
Women -- 15mg/day
Pregnant -- 30mg/day
Lactating -- 15mg/day
Iron's cousins are: Manganese, molybdenum, Vitamin E
and Vitamin B complex
Iron's aunts are: Calcium and phosphorus, which together
with iron must form a balance
MAGNESIUM - THE WONDER ELEMENT
Why do I call it the wonder element? It is the catalyst
for more enzymes in our bodies than any other element.
The magnesium activated enzymes are particularly
important in the metabolism of carbohydrates, amino
acids and the regulation of protein synthesis.
Men - 400-420 mg/day
Women - 310-320 mg/day
Pregnancy - 400 mg/day
Lactating - 360 mg/day
MANGANESE
PLEASE NOTE: In this series on trace
elements, I write ONLY about ORAL
comsumption of the element and ONLY
about the INORGANIC form of the element.
Cousins - Magnesium, zinc, selenium, Vitamin E,
Vitamin K
Aunts - Carbohydrate, fat and protein metabolism
High Amounts - 5mg/day
Super Amounts - 10mg/day
MERCURY
Mercury is of the same chemical family as zinc and cadmium. There are three forms of mercury, metallic mercury, inorganic mercury and organic mercury (including methylmercury). Metallic mercury was used in tooth filling amalgams. Health problems appear to have arisen from these mercury amalgam fillings in a small percentage of people, but are of a different type to those that can arise from the intake of methylmercury.
MOLYBDENUM
Molybdenum is a little known essential
trace element, that is a constituent of
several enzyme systems, particularly,
aldehyde oxidase, xanthine oxidase
and sulfite oxidase. There is also an
interesting triad balance system
involving molybdenum, copper and
sulfur metabolism.
Infants 0-0.5 years -- 15-30ug per day
Children 1-3 years -- 25-50ug per day
7-10years -- 50-150ug per day
Adults -- 75-250ug per day
Supplementation IS NOT RECOMMENDED
Cousins - Chromium(?), Vanadium(?),
manganese(?), lead(?),
tungsten(?), selenium(?) Br>
Aunts - Purines and other systems involving
the key enzymes of which
molybedenum is the cofactor.
SELENIUM
(From Selene, the Greek moon-goddess, often
portrayed with a scepter in her hand and riding
in a chariot drawn by two white horses).
Cousins - Mercury, cadmium, copper, silver, Vitamin C, zinc,
sulfur containing amino acids
Aunts - Proteins and sulfur metabolism, particularly, the
enzyme systems, succinic dehydrogenase, choline
oxidase and proline oxidase.
The measured daily amounts in the normal US diet is about
50-100ug/day
Excess Toxicity might probably occur as low as the range
750-1000ug/day (0.75-1.00mg/day) - hence you want
your TOTAL intake to be less than say 375ug/day, so
best if you want a supplement, have one containing no
more than say 200-300ug/day OR *better yet*, see that
your food intake of selenium is increased.
Deficiency Toxicity would probably occur in the range
10-25ug/day BUT depends on many factors.
SILICON
The trace mineral silicon is found in both plants and animals. Silicon is
not currently considered to be an essential element in humans, but
deficiencies have been reported in experiments performed on rats and chicks.
Silicon deficient chicks had abnormalities in their bones and joints, which
appeared to involve collagen and glycosaminoglycan formation. Silicon is
essential for some plants. In human diets, the daily intake of silicon is
in the 20-50mg range. Silicon is poorly absorbed from the diet. Claims
that supplemental siliconmight be of benefit in osteoporosis and in diseases
of the joints have not been confirmed.
TIN
Tin is not considered essential for humans. Tin deficiency has been created
in rats, leading to poor growth, alopecia and lowering of response to sound.
In humans, the daily dietary intake of tin is in the 1-40mg range. Although
studies in rats have suggested that tin may have an immune-modulating
activity, this has not been confirmed in humans. Supplemental tin is not
recommended for humans.
VANADIUM
Vanadium is widely distributed in nature. Vanadiun has not been established
as an essential trace element in humans. However, in goats deficient
animals had elevated spontaneous abortion rates and depressed milk
production, whereas deficient rats had decreased growth. Vanadium compounds
can mimic insulin, but since vanadium and its compounds are poorly absorbed
from the gut (less than 5%) an effective oral dose would likely be toxic.
However, some compounds such as vanadium-ligand-L-glutamic acid
gamma-mono-hydroxamate and a picolinato compound, both of which have a
higher therapeutic to toxicity ratio are being developed. The average daily
intake of vanadium is about 15mcg. Chromium (+3 not +6), iron (+2) and
aluminum hydroxide and chloride all decrease absorption of vanadium. It
should be noted that claims that vanadium increases muscle mass have been
refuted by scientific research.
ZINC - Sometimes called the Male Sexy Element.
Zinc is an important essential macro trace element
required by many enzymes in our bodies. It is
important for the normal function of the prostate gland,
and the growth and maturity of the male sex organs,
in burn and wound healing and in protein, carbohydrate
and energy metabolism. High levels of zinc are present
in the retina and it may be important in diseases of the
macular. Zinc is also a factor in how we perceived taste
and smell. In addition, it is needed for cell growth and
the proper metabolism of Vitamin A and phosphorus.
Cousins - Vitamins D, C and B6, calcium and iron
Aunts - Insulin, testosterone, growth hormone, protein
Males - 15 mg/day
Females - 12 mg/day
Pregnant - 15 mg/day
Lactating 16-19 mg/day